When comparing fresh dog food brands, Ollie Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog are two of the most popular options. Both offer human-grade, fresh meals delivered to your door, but there are important differences in ingredients, customization, price, and overall value. Understanding these differences can help you choose the best option for your dog while also avoiding unnecessary expense.
In this post, we’ll compare Ollie Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog side by side, answer common buyer questions, and help you decide which of these fresh dog food brands is right for your dog.
Before we compare these brands, try not to feel overwhelmed about choosing the “perfect” food for your dog. It’s important to do your research and understand your options, but the best choice is the one that fits both your dog’s needs and your budget.
Providing the highest-quality food you can realistically afford is what matters most. The fact that you’re taking the time to compare fresh dog food brands already shows that you’re a thoughtful and responsible dog owner. Both Ollie Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog are high-quality options, so you’re unlikely to make a wrong decision. Now, let’s take a closer look at how they compare.
👉 See current Ollie Dog Food discounts and how to customize your dog’s meal plan
This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I’ll earn a commission (at no extra cost to you). I donate 10% of my profits to animal charities.
Ollie Dog Food vs The Farmer’s Dog: Which is Better?
Both Ollie Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog provide fresh, human-grade dog food made with real ingredients and tailored to your dog’s age, weight, breed, and activity level. Meals are pre-portioned and delivered on a subscription basis, which makes feeding fresh food convenient for busy pet owners.
Ollie Dog Food stands out for offering both fresh and baked food options, allowing more flexibility in price and feeding style. The Farmer’s Dog focuses exclusively on fresh recipes that are gently cooked and delivered frozen.
Both brands are formulated to meet nutritional standards recognized by veterinary nutrition experts and are designed to be complete and balanced based on guidelines from the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).
For a deeper breakdown of ingredients, recipes, and overall value, see my full Ollie Dog Food review and my complete The Farmer’s Dog review.
Ollie Dog Food vs The Farmer’s Dog Ingredients Comparison
Both brands use high-quality protein sources such as beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb as the first ingredient. They also include vegetables, healthy fats, and essential vitamins and minerals. Meals are prepared in USDA-regulated kitchens and do not contain artificial preservatives or fillers commonly found in traditional kibble.
Ollie Dog Food recipes often include whole-food ingredients such as peas, carrots, and sweet potatoes, along with fish oil and other nutrient-rich additions. The Farmer’s Dog also uses whole ingredients and focuses on minimal processing to help preserve nutrients.
Many pet owners report improvements in digestion, coat condition, and overall energy after switching to fresh dog food.
Because both companies customize meals to your dog’s needs, the best choice often comes down to your dog’s preferences and any specific health considerations. You can explore ingredient details and recipe comparisons in my Ollie Dog Food Review and Farmer’s Dog Review.
Ollie Dog Food vs The Farmer’s Dog Cost: Which Is Cheaper?
Fresh dog food is more expensive than traditional kibble, but pricing depends on your dog’s size, calorie needs, and whether you use fresh food as a full diet or as a topper. Ollie Dog Food may be more budget-friendly for some households because it offers flexible feeding plans and baked options that can reduce the overall cost.
The Farmer’s Dog pricing is based on fully fresh meal plans, which may be higher in cost but may appeal to owners who want a complete fresh feeding approach. Both brands often offer introductory discounts that make it easier to test whether your dog enjoys the food before committing long term. (You’ll find discount links in this post, and in both of my reviews).
If your goal is better nutrition without overspending, Ollie’s flexibility and variety may be appealing. However, many owners prefer The Farmer’s Dog for its simplicity and fully fresh focus. Comparing customized plans is the best way to determine which option offers better value for your dog.
Summary: Ollie Dog Food vs The Farmer’s Dog
Both Ollie Dog Food and The Farmer’s Dog are high-quality fresh dog food brands focused on real ingredients, balanced nutrition, and convenience. The right choice depends on your budget, your dog’s preferences, and whether you want flexible or fully fresh feeding options.
Ollie Dog Food may be the better choice for owners looking for flexibility and value, while The Farmer’s Dog may appeal to those who want a simple, fully fresh approach.
If you’d like more help to decide which is best for your dog, read my full comparison and ingredient breakdown in my Ollie Dog Food review and The Farmer’s Dog review, and compare personalized meal plans before ordering.
Thank you for stopping by! I hope this information helps you to make the best decision for your dog’s best health. Your dog is very fortunate to have you! Debra
👉 Take advantage of current Ollie Dog Food discounts and customize your dog’s meal plan now
More Dog Food Reviews and Posts You Might Like
- Ollie Dog Food Review
- The Farmer’s Dog Review
- A Pup Above Dog Food Review
- The Farmer’s Dog vs. Homemade Dog Food
- Ollie Dog Food vs. The Farmer’s Dog
- Fresh Dog Food Comparisons and Reviews
💬 Did this help you? If you have a question, helpful tips, or even a struggle related to this topic, please leave a comment below — it helps other readers more than you know.
Pin it for Later!
