Fresh Dog Food Comparisons and Reviews

Fresh dog food is becoming an increasingly popular choice for pet parents who want to feed their dogs healthier, more natural meals. Unlike kibble or canned food, fresh dog food is made with whole, human-grade ingredients, often prepared in USDA-certified kitchens and delivered right to your door. But with so many options, how do you know which brand is best for your dog?

In this article, we compare five of the top fresh dog food brands—The Farmer’s Dog, Nom Nom, A Pup Above, Evermore, and Ollie—so you can make an informed decision. We’ll cover their ingredients, quality, pricing, and pros and cons.

I’ll sum it up for you at the end of this post and I’ll also share several more affordable, healthy options you can find on Amazon.

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I’ll earn a commission (at no extra cost to you). As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I donate 10% of my earnings to animal charities. 

Fresh Dog Food Comparison Chart

The Farmer’s Dog

• • Quality: Human-grade, cooked fresh, vet-formulated
  • Ingredients: USDA meats, fresh vegetables, no preservatives
  • Pricing: Starts around $2–$12/day depending on dog size and plan
  • Pros:
    • Great for picky eaters
    • Pre-portioned meals
    • Vet-formulated
  • Cons:
    • Subscription only
    • No one-time purchase

Read my full review of The Farmer’s Dog here, or check out their website and get 50% off your first order!

Nom Nom Dog Food

• • Quality: Fresh, restaurant-quality ingredients
  • Ingredients: Turkey, beef, chicken, vegetables, minimal processing
  • Pricing: Starts around $3/day for small dogs
  • Pros:
    • Excellent for allergy-prone dogs
    • Individually packaged meals
    • Probiotic support included
  • Cons:
    • Subscription required
    • Limited customization

Read my full review of Nom Nom dog food here, or visit their website for 50% off your first order!  I did a video where I reviewed Nom Nom dog food and also discussed how to make good decisions regarding your dog’s diet.  You can watch it here if you like.

A Pup Above

• • Quality: Sous-vide cooking, human-grade, ethically sourced
  • Ingredients: Real meat, bone broth, vegetables
  • Pricing: $3–$10/day depending on dog size
  • Pros:
    • Rich in flavor and moisture
    • No subscription required
    • Ethical sourcing
  • Cons:
    • Higher price point
    • Not ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs

Read my full review of A Pup Above dog food here, or visit their website and get 50% off your first order!

Evermore

• • Quality: Organic produce, grass-fed meats, no fillers
  • Ingredients: High-quality proteins, organic veggies, no by-products
  • Pricing: $4–$13/day depending on dog size
  • Pros:
    • Organic and transparent sourcing
    • Sustainable packaging
    • No artificial preservatives
  • Cons:
    • Premium price
    • Smaller variety menu

Ollie

• Quality: Vet-designed, minimally processed, human-grade
• Ingredients: Beef, turkey, lamb, and chicken options with produce
• Pricing: ~$2–$9/day
• Pros:
  • More affordable than others
  • Easy onboarding quiz
  • Nutrient-dense meals
• Cons:
  • Subscription only
  • Less exotic protein options

You can read my full review of Ollie Dog Food here.

More Affordable Healthy Dog Food Options (Amazon Picks)

If a fresh dog food subscription service isn’t in your budget, consider these healthy alternatives available on Amazon:

The Honest Kitchen Dehydrated Dog Food

• • Just add water
  • Human-grade
  • More affordable long-term

Spot & Tango UnKibble

• • Fresh dry food alternative
  • No artificial additives
  • Whole-food ingredients

Wellness Core RawRev

• • Kibble with freeze-dried raw meat
  • Higher protein content

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula

• • No corn, wheat, or soy
  • Enhanced with vitamins and antioxidants

Which Dog Food is Right for You?

Best for allergies: Nom Nom
Best gourmet meals: A Pup Above
Best organic option: Evermore
Best for picky eaters: The Farmer’s Dog
Best budget-friendly fresh food: Ollie
Best non-subscription healthy food: Honest Kitchen, Spot & Tango

Choosing fresh food is one of the best decisions you can make for your dog’s health. Every dog is different, so consider your pup’s needs—and your budget—when deciding.Ready to upgrade your dog’s food? Use the links above to order and get special discounts where available.

Is Feeding Your Dog Fresh Dog Food Worth the Extra Cost?

Check out my post, Is Fresh Dog Food Worth the Cost? – let’s talk!  Also check out this post from Dog Advisor.com about best dog foods. 

Dog Nutrition & Feeding Guides

• Incorporating Vegetables into Your Dog’s Diet
• How to Help Your Dog Lose Weight (Dog Obesity is More Dangerous Than You Think)
• Best and Worst Foods for Your Pet: How to Know Which Ones to Buy
• Foods That Are Poisonous for Dogs and Cats
• Feeding Your New Puppy: Proper Puppy Nutrition
• Best Dog Food for Sensitive Stomachs

I Donate to Animal Charities

Thank you for visiting my site!  I hope this dog food comparison post has helped you decide which food to feed your dog.  Your dog is very fortunate to have an owner who loves them enough to put effort into choosing the right dog food for them!

You should know I will receive a small commission if you purchase any of these dog foods using the links in this post.  I donate 10% of my profits to the animal charities shown here. 

If you were helped by my website, please share it with other pet lovers.  Thank you!  Debra

Check Out More of My Posts About Dog Health Here